E- Mail needs to be decentralized again

And thats not a new idea that came to my mind when the world stood still last week because the O365 services by Microsoft were not reachable. One service that was really problematic was their E-mail service in Exchange Online and O365.

That showed us how important E-Mail is even today. Its not only a medium that nearly everybody uses (even people without smartphone or which are very privacy focused), but it is also often an anchor of trust. Nearly every service uses it for password recovery, or even replaces passwords with it sending one-time codes for login. Simply take a short moment to think about what would not work for you if youre E-Mail setup would stop functioning.

Normally i would say the E-Mail system is quite resilient, how it is concepted. The specs are free, everybody could write software for it. Everybody with a bit of knowledge could run its own mailserver. If there are enough of it, one failing shouldnt be an issue.

Unfortunately thats not the case anymore. If you have a look at the study by Validity approx. 73% of the E-Mail accounts in the study are located at Google (42,9%), Yahoo (15,7%) and Microsoft (14,4%). Thats a lot of power in the hands of a few techbros.

Its not surprising that Google holds the biggest share here. An E-Mail Service is a gold mine of personal Information. Normally E-Mails are not end to end encrypted what differs them from services like Signal. If you are lucky they are TLS encrypted between the mailservers but they are stored unencrypted in your mailbox. Thats perfect for companies like Google which love to extract your data. Just think about what kind of info is in your mailbox. And than think again if it is a good idea that an unencrypted copy of sensible information is stored there.

Bigtech companie like Google aren’t providing you such a service because they are good people, they want to make money selling your data, without you noticing it. Thats what we call enshittfication. They attract you with free unlimited storage funded by venture capital. When its payback time they squeeze money out of you. They wait till changing the service is so complicated for you that it really hurts. From there on they can do nearly anything. Charging for subscriptions, extract your personal data, integrate ads, or make the service worse to save costs. That also works for companies too. Btw. the same is done by AI Companies right now. Works all the time.

But how do you keep such a service growing when you make it worse. How can you pull the customers from other mail poviders? You need to convince people that you are the only choice if they want to be sure that their mails reach the recipient.

Spammers and other criminals to the rescue. The base of our E-Mail system dates back to RFC822 from 1982. Back than such systems were build on trust, the user base was small. So people which abused the system could be identified. But trust does not scale really good. And so criminals found out that you can make money sending unwanted ads. As a countermeasure the Spam filters were intruduced, which does not solve the problem because everybody can run a mailverser. But it hides the problem from the user. Such an intrasperent system where the company that runs the mailserver decides what the user will see is a real big present for companies like Google. They hate transperancy for a good reason.

I run tow mailservers, and delivering Mails to Google and Microsoft tend to be an adventure. You can differ two cases:

  1. The Mail is rejected by the mailserver and you get an error message, for example that Microsoft blocked the whole IP Range of your hoster for whatever reason. Now you can try to get your IP delisted in a confusing intransperent procedure. Of course the hosters only do that to small mailhosters and selfhosters. Microsoft would never simple block Google etc.
  2. The server accepts the mail but instead of it going to the inbox of the user, it is flagged as spam. This also happens for replies to an mail a user sent me. Thats pretty sick. Just asked yourself how often you have looked throught your spam folder in the last couple of months. The sender does not get any error messages etc. Also the process of getting a reputation so your mails go into the inbox are quite a fuck up.

The second case shows how Bigtech uses its power. In the end they tell their users that only they can run reliable mailservices. I have seen that so many times. The last time at the parents conference in my kids school, where most of the parents use GMail (even in Europe) . The Mails from my perfectly setup mailserver (with SPF, DKIM, DMARC) were regulary flagged as spam. In the end i sended the mails from my Web.de account.

Whats really fucked up because according to the Phishing Activity Trends Report of APWG 66% of the phishing mails come from Google and 16% from Microsoft. While blocking others, they dont even solve the problem in their own company. Instead they are running huge spam and phishing networks, you could label as Crime-as-a-Service. But okay they are too big to care and too big to jail.

And when i have a look at our Forum registrations, nearly every spammer uses a GMail account, if they were not that big we would have to block them (too big to fail).

The good thing is, we could still make a change. Every person, every company. Big Tech has not succeeded killing alternative mailproviders or the software it needs by introducing their standards. Everyone changing to an alternative makes us more resilient to outages like the one on the 11-12.11.2026, which causes billions of damage, but Microsoft will not be accountable for that.

Everybody can migrate its E-Mails away from Google and Microsoft to one aof the many Freemailers (like GMX, Web.de, Proton) or to paid ones like Posteo or Mailbox.org. You can also get a mail account at your ISP, but i like to seperate that.

Enthusiasts which run an own homepage could also check if there are inboxes provided with the webspace. Than you can use that with your own domain. How cool is that?

If you are really hardcore you run your own mailserver on a VPS.

Also for companies its no big deal, and it really becomes an advantage at the next Microsoft outage. You know Microsoft fired 36% of their staff in the last two years replacing them by AI? Didnt see AI magically resolving last weeks problems.

Really think about a change. Maby you have a Di.Day near you. Or you just do it by yourself using a good How To. Its really not that hard

It will be good for all of us. The system only stay resilient when it is decentralized, which was the plan back in the days. But Google and Microsoft had other plans which are not for our advantage.

Björns Techblog
Björns Techblog
@blog@blog.sengotta.net
368 Beiträge
84 Folgende
Fediverse-Reaktionen

Schreibe einen Kommentar